Top 10 Greek Restaurants to Try in Indianapolis, IN

Indianapolis may be known as the Crossroads of America, but the city also sits at an underappreciated crossroads of Greek dining that stretches from a downtown institution that has been serving authentic Greek cuisine since 1987 to a family restaurant that has appeared on Indianapolis Monthly's Top 25 Restaurants list consistently since 2004. The Indy Greek food scene is spread across the city's neighborhoods and suburbs and rewards those willing to explore it. Please note that the restaurants below are not listed in any particular order. Every spot on this list is worth a visit in its own right.

The Greek Islands Restaurant

Indianapolis's oldest Greek restaurant and a downtown institution since 1987, The Greek Islands Restaurant is the standard-bearer for authentic Greek cuisine in the city and a beloved family-owned establishment that has been welcoming Hoosiers for over three decades. The hummus is widely considered the best in Indianapolis, the flaming cheese saganaki is the heavy favorite among regulars, and the menu spans eggplant moussaka, ground beef pastitsio, kreatopita meat pie, tender lamb chops, chicken souvlaki, and Greek spaghetti with genuine depth and care. The staff makes every guest feel like family from the first visit.

Santorini Greek Kitchen

A family restaurant that has appeared on Indianapolis Monthly's Top 25 Restaurants in Indianapolis list consistently since 2004, Santorini Greek Kitchen is one of the most celebrated and dependable Greek dining destinations in the city. The rack of lamb, fish kabobs, mixed grill platter, and half and half platter are all signature dishes, every meal comes with a Greek salad, rice pilaf, Mediterranean green beans, and Greek potatoes, and the belly dancing on Friday and Saturday nights adds a festive energy that makes every visit feel like an occasion. It is an absolute gem of a neighborhood restaurant.

Athens on 86th

A well-loved Indianapolis Greek restaurant that has been earning loyal regulars since 2004 and bills itself as the best Greek restaurant in Indianapolis, Athens on 86th delivers consistently excellent food in a warm and welcoming atmosphere where the ownership is present and attentive on every visit. The spanakopita, falafel, and gyros are all executed with care, the baklava with vanilla ice cream is a perfect finish, and the service is described as super by regulars who have been coming for over two decades without a disappointing meal.

OPA!

A well-regarded Indianapolis Greek restaurant that has built a reputation for its authentic Greek street food approach and rustic old-world atmosphere, OPA! is one of the more distinctive and enjoyable Greek dining experiences in the city. The food is prepared with genuine attention to Greek culinary traditions, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the overall experience captures the casual festive spirit that makes Greek food so satisfying. It is a strong option for anyone looking for honest and flavorful Greek street food across Indianapolis.

Petra Cafe Downtown

A well-regarded Greek and Mediterranean cafe in downtown Indianapolis that earns strong praise for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere, Petra Cafe is one of the most convenient and satisfying Greek dining options in the heart of the city. The gyros and baklava are both consistently excellent, the food is fresh and prepared with care, and the overall quality and value make it a natural go-to for a satisfying Greek meal in the downtown core.

Canal Bistro Mediterranean Grille

A Mediterranean restaurant in Indianapolis that earns consistent praise for its authentic and flavorful Greek and Mediterranean cooking, Canal Bistro Mediterranean Grille is a solid and satisfying option for Greek food across the city. The menu covers the Mediterranean classics with care and the overall experience reflects a genuine commitment to quality ingredients and honest cooking that has built it a loyal following across the Indianapolis dining community.

The Med

A well-loved Indianapolis Mediterranean and Greek restaurant that consistently appears among the top-rated Greek spots in the city and delivers fresh and flavorful food with warm and welcoming service, The Med is a dependable and enjoyable option for Greek cuisine across Indianapolis. The food is authentic and well-prepared, the atmosphere is comfortable, and the overall quality makes it a reliable neighborhood favorite worth knowing about.

Mama Fofos

A beloved Indianapolis Greek spot that has earned a devoted local following for its generous portions, warm atmosphere, and honest Greek cooking, Mama Fofos is one of those neighborhood restaurants that quickly becomes a regular haunt for anyone who discovers it. The food is made with genuine care and reflects a real love of Greek culinary traditions, and the welcoming service makes every guest feel at home from the very first visit.

King Gyros

A popular Indianapolis Greek spot that consistently earns strong marks for its gyros and straightforward Greek street food, King Gyros is a reliable and satisfying casual option for Greek food across the city. The gyros are well-made with quality ingredients, the portions are generous, and the overall value and consistency make it one of the most dependable options for a quick and satisfying Greek meal anywhere in Indianapolis.

Adel's Gyros

A well-regarded Indianapolis gyro spot that delivers authentic and flavorful Greek street food with the kind of fresh ingredients and genuine quality that earns a restaurant its loyal regulars, Adel's Gyros is a solid and satisfying casual Greek dining option across the city. The gyros are consistently praised for their flavor and quality, and the overall experience reflects a straightforward commitment to doing simple Greek food well every time.

Conclusion

Indianapolis has a Greek food scene that runs deeper than most visitors to the Crossroads of America ever discover, from a beloved downtown institution with nearly forty years of history to family-run neighborhood restaurants that have been quietly earning their regulars for decades. There is more authentic Greek dining worth finding across the city and its suburbs than any single visit can fully cover.